Welcome to San Diego Blog | April 11, 2019
Scooters … To Be Or Not To Be?
People seem to fall into only one of two camps on the subject of ride-sharing scooters which have popped up in every nook and cranny of the country, including our beautiful San Diego. Either folks are for them, it seems, or against them. Sadly, this largely uncontrolled craze has experienced a lot of negative press as well as a few deaths, which fuels the argument in favor of banning them altogether.
If I remember American history correctly, people in general were strongly opposed to the “motor car” when they first hit the roads in the late 1800s due in large part to the noise, the nuisance, and the danger (people were splashed with mud by passing vehicles and startled – sometimes nearly killed – by careening carriages that seemed to come out of nowhere). Until the 1920s traffic and automobile safety standards were inconsistent. For an interesting read on the history of traffic laws click here.
Ever since I became aware of scooters I have been scratching my head over the lack of regulations. Here is why. I happen to ride a Harley. It’s my passion when I’m not working with buyers and sellers of residential real estate. In California, motorcycle equipment laws specify the following for all motorcycles:
- After 1973, motorcycles must be equipped with lamp-type turn signal systems.
- Headlamp modulators are permitted but may not be used during darkness.
- After 1978, motorcycles must be equipped with at least 1 and not more than 2 head-lamps that turn on automatically when the engine is started and remain lighted while the engine is running.
- Motorcycles must have at least 1 mirror located so as to give the driver a view of at least 200 feet to the rear of the vehicle.
- All riders and passengers of motorcycles and mopeds must wear a safety helmet.
I believe that all scooters (whether ride-share or individually owned) and their riders should be required to follow the same laws as those set forth for motorcycle drivers and passengers. The only difference between the two – motorcycles and scooters – is size and in most cases, speed. And as we’ve seen lately, scooters can go fast enough to kill its rider(s).
Here is another compelling comparison: Motorcycles are not allowed to be operated on sidewalks and boardwalks for obvious safety reasons. Why are scooters allowed there? The risk of peril for pedestrians and riders is the same, is it not?
We must be consistent and thoughtful in the way we regulate this wonderful “new” form of transportation. If we allow scooters to be operated on roadways with other motorized vehicles, the equipment requirements should be similar, and the driver requirements of helmet and safety goggles should be enforced. If we allow scooters only on sidewalks, and boardwalks (i.e. “off road”) then scooters should be limited to a very slow speed and must feature some sort of bell or horn that alerts pedestrians as to its presence when in operation.
This is my opinion. I invite your thoughtful comments. For this, or anything about San Diego, San Diego County, the experience of living in this awesome area, or our terrific real estate options, contact me!
Arlis W. Travis 619-876-0247 or firstname.lastname@example.org